Writers who committed suicide is a big list.

If we can expand the sample beyond "people famous enough to have pages on Wikipedia", this UK analysis has the highest suicide rates for male vets and female gov inspectors. ... In the US, white female artists are mentioned again, along with white male physicians and black guards. ... Overall, I'd say that economics and politics have lot more to do with suicide rates than chosen careers.

But it's not the same thing, is it? Lots of people commit suicide. I thought David was simply saying the number of writers who do is pretty high. But don't you have to compare the number of artists total to the number of vets or government inspectors or physicians or guards, to draw a conclusion about the percentage of each who commits suicide?

Miracleman's post reminds me that while I am alive and therefore could create something theoretically, the meds, in large doses, completely wipe out the desire to create.

I get this. And I think it's a problem not just for creative people, but a lot of people. I know my sister-in-law went off one med, because she hated the feeling of *not* feeling anything, good or bad. She was too flat on the meds.

Also, I would put craft and art into the same conceptual bin, so closely that on odd days I would say they're the same thing.

I think they're related, but craft is more about facility and technical skill rather than intent and expression. For example, as an illustrator and painter I consider myself a fairly skilled craftsman and I can usually draw upon those skills to create work of some quality when needed. But I only occasionally feel inspired to act in the capacity of an artist, create something for the sake of creating.

Art.

Art art art. The word has lost all meaning.

Except that it's what you call a guy with no arms or legs who's hanging on a wall.

a guy with no arms or legs who's hanging on a wall.

Now, that dude has earned the right to a good bout of mental illness.

I think it's fair to say that art is frequently an interactive process in that the audience may see something very different from what the author intended. Not least because each member of the audience brings a different world view to the experience of the work.

Witness: the Left Behind books. Because of a fundamental difference in world view the authors and people who like those books see great art. Those who do not share their world view see outlandishly massive flaws in the work, and gain insight into the mind of the authors that the authors themselves cannot see.

I think they're related, but craft is more about facility and technical skill rather than intent and expression.

Particularly in the theater and film industries, but also in art in general, I would argue that they are equal parts facility/technical skill and intent/expression. It was an interesting try at an argument, but I've seen enough facility and technical skill on display in most art to find this argument to not hold water.

For example, as an illustrator and painter I consider myself a fairly skilled craftsman and I can usually draw upon those skills to create work of some quality when needed. But I only occasionally feel inspired to act in the capacity of an artist, create something for the sake of creating.

I feel the same way, as a writer.

I think I met that guy at a conference, once.

Actually, and as a side note on the art/craft distinction, there's a lot to be said about whose craft is art, and whose art is craft, to paraphrase George Carlin. Anyway, quite a lot of tranditionally female-oriented activities get dismissed for being "just a craft," while activities that men dominate are called art, or are called art when they're doing it. Like how no man is a cook in the kitchen, he's always a chef.

Which is one of the reasons I'm reluctant to create a sharp distinction between the two.

For some reason the art/craft discussion has made me flash on the "death is your art" line from Buffy. Was it really her art, or was it her craft? I'd say the lines definitely blurred at times (using her skills on routine patrol being craft, while a more personal use of her skills probably edged over towards art).

For some reason the art/craft discussion has made me flash on the "death is your art" line from Buffy. Was it really her art, or was it her craft? I'd say the lines definitely blurred at times (using her skills on routine patrol being craft, while a more personal use of her skills probably edged over towards art).

Well, based on Tom Scola's criteria, which work as well as any, it was her art...because it definitely rated high on the Coolness axis.