I'm really torn on that routine. I liked it, Mia really pushes the envelope with some of the stuff she choreographs and that was cool. But, I think too much of the routine relied on the mattress. Dancing is done on the floor. There was no pair work to speak of. Still, I liked it. I thought they performed it with passion and grace. Yet. Yet. Argh! I don't know that I'd vote for it, despite the fact it was excellent and I'm afraid the voting public will feel the same way.

Very much this.

Also, for those at home keeping score:
Kherington: 5
High Heel Shoes: 0

So, I was very excited to see 55 posts here tonight before I started watching, and then I was watching the show, and my friend Rachel came by, and we ended up going to dinner, and I was like "Ack! Now I have to wait to see what people say!"

I'm sorry, was there dancing? I was completely distracted by Will's insanely, smoking hot body. GOOD LORD!!

Amen!!!

I really want Thayne gone, just because every time he smiles, I see his gums and they scare me.

Also, someone in costuming hates Matt, because his outfit in the hiphop, with the white suit?? Just made him seem even MORE whiteboy than he already is. Which is pretty damn whiteboy.

And their mambo was SO WHITE. It had no soul. It had no hips. There was no fire. I was like "My god, have you two never had any sex in your entire LIVES??? Or even made OUT with someone? JESUS!"

Someone in the costume department DOES love Mark. Because he needs to LIVE in a suit. But I felt bad for Chelsie, because she looked like she was wearing somethign a 90 year old rich woman who loves her 13 poodles should wear. Or possibly who is WEARING her 13 poodles. OMG.

I liked both of Mia's pieces, but I wanted the bed one to be longer--I felt like it would tell a better story if she had the whole song. And i felt like throwing actual rose petals was a little cheesy. I liked the actual dancing of the other one better, but I like when there's a story, and the bed one had more of a story.

I HATE Benji's West Coast Swings. I didn't like the one he choreographed last year either. West Coast Swing, when done NORMALLY? Is SEXY AS FUCK. When he choreographs it? It's weird. The stuff he danced season 2 was good, but when he does it for other people it just looks weird. I don't get it.

Although I'm crying a little on the inside when I think about Evan from the Top 20 doing that number. Crying

OMG, the guy who did the 40s routine with the hat?? He would be HOT.

I was very excited to see Kherington (a) do a routine in shoes and (b) do a routine where she wasn't smiling, but I was a little disappointed that that paso doble didn't seem to have a lot of paso doble, and had more tricks and cape swirling and less actual dancing, it seemed.

The last 30 Days (gun control) surprised me - my knee-jerk reaction was to be annoyed that they didn't do it the other way round (sending a gun nut to live with gun control activists), but it wound up being a really good episode. I was disappointed that the host was such a condescending prick, though - seriously dude, saying things like "Well, who hasn't lost a loved one to gun violence?" as if it were no big deal? Not helping your cause!

Kim Vo is scary! Like a modern Ken Doll.

I loved the Mia routines.

And although last week I hated the guest judge because he took forever to get going and then talked forever AT LEAST HE TALKED ABOUT THE DANCING.

Bottom 3: Matt/Kourtni, Thayne/Comfort, either Will/Jessica or Twitch/Kherington.

I think it might be Thayne & Kourtni going. I liked Kourtni in try-out a lot, but I don't think she can handle the range of dancing required. Maybe Jessica instead though?

Matt/Comfort would be odd, right? Will/Comfort still odd, but better? How much do you think the judges consider the match-ups they will leave when voting off?

SYTYCD- Last night's 2nd dance was the first time I didn't hate Jessica, but it's still too little too late. And Comfort has never blown me away the way I feel like she was set up to do, but that may just be me. She could coast by as a hip-hopper for awhile, but having seen the other dancers have much more versatility, I'm tired of waiting for her breakout week.

Can someone explain West Coast Swing to me? Because I didn't feel the chemistry last night, maybe I was distracted by the cheesy costumes but Joshua and Katee didn't seem to own it, they seemed very aware of the cheese factor- so if it's a dance done with irony I guess that's ok.

30 Days- I told my husband while watching it that I wish there could be a followup that was reversed, where the gun toting people went to live in the city and saw that gun violence is a real issue, and came to associate guns with crime or drugs or drivebys. I'm sure some of them would feel even more like they needed a gun for their own protection from that crime, but really, what can you do about getting hit by stray bullets? A gun isn't going to help you out much if you don't even know where the shooting is coming from. After moving from Seattle to Montana 3 years ago, I still can't adjust to so many people having guns. I know now how many people have concealed weapons just walking around the mall, and it's been explained to me that you don't go anywhere without your gun or you'd feel like part of you was missing, but I still just don't understand.

I was very excited to see Kherington (a) do a routine in shoes

Well, boots. But at least they had heels, although still not the spiky ones that everyone else has to dance in.

I did the fast forward/rewatch test this morning. For the first time, I didn't rewatch Mark/Chelsie. I did stop on the Joshua/Katee contemporary, Thayne/Comfort's smooth waltz, Will/Jessica's shirt number, and the bed number. The latter didn't seem any better, in fact it seemed even less dancy and more contrived. Although I still think the shirt number is too prop-based, it improved on rewatch. I half rewatched Benji's number, but it was just too damn slow for swing.

I do think it is time for Matt/Kourtni to go, I would sort of like to see Jessica and Thayne go and see what Will and Comfort could do together.

The problem with the WCS, it seems to me, is that it was too slow.

It looked like the could have picked it up just a notch and been successful. That cartwheel thing should have been taken out altogether because they just couldn't do it, but a different ending could have been choreographed.

OK, so I'm having a hard time finding a good youtube clip, because the problem is, much like competition ballroom waltzing is ridiculous looking oftentimes just because of the costumes, competition west coast swinging is often ridiculously cheesy. Much like how Benji does it.

But non-competition west coast swinging (which doesn't end up being the stuff on youtube) is HOT.

If you ignore the crowd cheering, and look the the individual moves (and not the group), you can kinda see it in this group dance here. Really, what I'm saying is, I like the basic stuff. Or when the really good people improv, rather than competition dance. But even then, there's a little too much performance to it, and not enough paying attention to your partner and the connection between you, which is what makes it sexy for me, as a performance.

There's a reason that everyone I know who sees it done in the club by people who are good at it goes "Ooh. I want to learn how to do THAT". Two step is fun and all, but people just want to learn it so they can dance. When they see people west coast swinging, it's like "Damn, that looks sexy"

This is maybe a dumb question, but is there East Coast Swing?