BSG

While we enjoy this brief hiatus, I wanted to start up the discussion on the game elements we'll use for the next flight of the Buffistica. Our last couple of games have used the base game, as well as the standard elements of both the Pegasus and Exodus expansions. I think that's worked pretty well. However, we can change things up for the next game if people want. Options:

1. Go retro. We can take out Exodus, or Pegasus, or both, to make a simpler game. Our first six games (I think) all just used the base game.

2. Add moar. Both Pegasus and Exodus have mroe options that we could try if people wanted some more variety. A very fast recap of what's available:

Pegasus
New Caprica.
You head for New Caprica instead of Kobol. At Distance 7, you wind up there, on a new gameboard, under Cylon occupation. After one jump cycle, Galactica returns and you have one last shootout. Once the Admiral's happy with the number of civvies rescued, he orders the final jump.

Cylon leaders:
One player takes Cavil, Leoben or Six. They have a hidden agenda, which sees them favouring one team or the other, and there's another condition they have to meet as well.

Exodus
Conflicted Loyalties.
Some "You are not a Cylon" loyalty cards now carry an extra sting. You might have a Personal Goal that sees you working against the crew (or risk a resource); or you might be one of the Final Five. If anyone else finds out, Bad Things Happen. This is an easy expansion to include, but it's firmly biased towards the Cylons.

Cylon Fleet Board.
Replaces the crisis attack cards. Instead, the Cylons are always in relentles pursuit, and when they reach the end of the pursuit track, in they jump. Jumping away earns a respite, but anything not destroyed will still find you again. The humans get some extra tools for the job, like better Vipers and a new office, that of CAG.

Ionian Nebula.
Players are heading for a Crossroads at Distance 8. Along the way, you can accumulate trauma. Gain too much, and you may not survive the Crossroads. There are also allies scattered in locations around the fleet. Encountering them could help, or hurt. (THIS OPTION INCLUDES PLAYER ELIMINATION.)

I have my own opinions about the various expansion options, but I'll run anything. Let's get a conversation started. Do people want more? Want less? Just want ND to not be a Cylon this time?

ND could be the Cylon leader!

BSG

I am game for any of them. Either or both of the Pegasus options would be fun to try out. The Exodus ones seem more complicated for now.

I want to be Six!

I'm game for more.

I am game for any of them. Either or both of the Pegasus options would be fun to try out. The Exodus ones seem more complicated for now.

My assessment there:

Of all the available modules of both sets, Conflicted Loyalties is undoubtedly the easiest to use and implement. Cylon Leader is next easiest. The other three (New Caprica, Cylon Fleet Board, Ionian Nebula) all add significantly to the game's complexity, and make it a fairly different experience. Ionian Nebula is probably the most complex.

When I first read it over I thought cylon leaders sounded too complicated but the two additions that sound the most fun to me (New Caprica and Cylon Feet) turn out to be more complicated. I'm all for simplicity but I really like the added peril (and realism) of relentless cylon pursuit. It would certainly make it a lot less likely for Team Human to win in a walk.

I think I'd probably be more interested in the Pegasus modules before the Exodus ones. I think I'd want to do those too eventually, but I don't want to add too much complexity all at once.

We could probably do both Pegasus modules at once, really, since New Caprica doesn't affect the game at all until the end.

I could go for CL and CL, and maybe CF, since that's mostly new bookkeeping for the GM. I think I'd vote against either new destination, at least for now.

Sounds like there's some interest in expanding the options for the next game. I'm thinking the first step is to whittle down all the options to the ones in which there's strong interest. Then we can work out what to do from there. (I recommend we add one, and strongly recommend against adding more than two.)

So, could everyone indicate, for each available element, whether you think it should be under consideration, or ruled out. Voting on:

Cylon Leader
New Caprica
Conflicted Loyalties
Cylon Fleet
Ionian Nebula